I'm thinking I love it...however you are the one who has to love it. If even one thing bothers you about this bag, I'd send it back...if you spend good money on a bag, you should LOVE it. But...I do love it. Do you think you would mind posting modelling pics? I haven't seen it modelled w/ the shorter straps yet.
Edit: so you are saying the hw looks sort of cheap...hmm...that would probably hinder me from keeping it too....I wish I had a boutique around here so I could check it out myself!!! Gah! It looks so nice and smooshy though! TBH..it doesn't look that much different from my Julianne, especially if the straps are only long enough to be hand held!