Hi,
Congrats!!! I say go with the bag you like!!! The carryall was nice but this Peyton does have a pop to it!!! I have also seen it IRL. She is Beautiful!!!! (wish it had a long strap too!!! ) I like the availability of both!!! Enjoy!!!
Lynne
Beautiful bag...such a pretty fresh color for spring!!
I tried it on yet again yesterday and I"m still loving the bag, why is that the case? LOL... I'm seriously considering it for PCE... have you worn yours yet? If I get one, I'm also getting the regular size, it will fit a ton! Both sizes are adorable thoughita coach girl! i thought it was kind of meh, but, then today i tried it on and then i even got it in a color i would never think of getting it in!!!! i love it! the acorn spectator is a gorgeous bag but i needed something different...how many seasons do you think this bag is wearable?
I would consider it more of a Salmon than orange.