As for the color matching, I've never been one to worry about matching. I carry what I feel like without regard to being color coordinated.....that being said, I've seen the bag before, but I've never owned it, so I might would have been a little more conscientious of not wearing clashing colors if I had owned it......as in no bright purple shirts with the green bag. As for the shininess, that's more of a personal preference. I wouldn't think shininess would be much of a consideration for matching or coordinating....maybe that's just me. It's a nice summery colored bag and if you like it, buy it. If it makes you happy, don't worry about what anyone else thinks about it. Sabrina is a nice bag, I had it in black.