I have a very nice Oroton black leather wallet with a silver metal "O" clasp, that I bought at TJ Maxx about 7 or 8 years ago. It still had the retail tag, and I think full price was in the $200-$250 range. I would agree, it was about in line with my Coach or Lodis wallets. It is a very nice wallet and held up very well - I still carry it from time to time!
I have never heard of or seen fake Oroton products. Since it isn't a very well-known brand outside of Australia, I would be very surprised if the bags are not authentic. Not saying they aren't good bags or good quality, they just aren't as "sought after" or recognizable as say, Coach "C" print or LV monogram, to be faked. People want a fake of something recognizable, not a brand that most people in the US haven't heard of.
Looking forward to seeing pictures!