My answer...it depends... For me each bag stands on its own..."magic" depends on leather/color/size/style/HW in combination...
I expected to LOVE swift...but...fortunately...the large Alaska store had several swift Kelly bags on display and I quickly learned this was not my own best match...although I would not rule it out w/o seeing it in a Birkin as well...because I might just need a bit more structure/seaming to the leather to enjoy... I have seen bags I LOVED in togo and those I did not care for... East Alaska is such a great place to investigate leather...color...etc... Both in the store and on the street...
I expected to LOVE swift...but...fortunately...the large Alaska store had several swift Kelly bags on display and I quickly learned this was not my own best match...although I would not rule it out w/o seeing it in a Birkin as well...because I might just need a bit more structure/seaming to the leather to enjoy... I have seen bags I LOVED in togo and those I did not care for... East Alaska is such a great place to investigate leather...color...etc... Both in the store and on the street...