Orange Poppy vs. Feu

If you want a true orange, perhaps feu is for you. It is more of a neutral orange (if there is such a thing, I do realize) meaning not too bright and not too muted.

Orange poppy was first described to me by my SA prior to seeing it as more of a neon orange. While I don't agree with the neon descriptor, I totally got what she was saying when I first saw it -- it is certainly more of a "pop" orange hue.
 
I think that you really need to decide which of the two strikes you.....we all have differing tastes. Go with your gut and choose the one that screams "take me home, mama"!
 
I am torn between the two colors. For me it seems like orange poppy has a more of a red tone thank Feu. I want to have a really shining color and I have seen many pics where Feu simply looks gorgeous but also some where it looks a little bit dull.
If you had the choice what would you prefer?

Here is a comparison pic (inside lightinh), feu chevre karo and orange poppy rodeo against the H orange box.

IMG_6648_zps0bw9jxn8.jpg