Orange or Burgundy Paddy Clutch?

I just received the Mahogany paddy clutch I had ordered from Bluefly. Seems authentic but I'm not an expert (all my knowledge comes from the reading this forum!) Chloe-babe, you're right. It's a lot smaller than I thought! I will be returning it and looking for a slightly larger clutch. Any suggestions are welcome!
 
New Dilemma: I ended up going on AR and bought the pewter clutch at 50% off and just got an email from AR saying that one of the metal studs had fallen off. My 2 options: cancel order or have AR ship it back to Chloe for repairs.

What should I do? Seems like a really good deal but not sure about getting a defective product.