I'm on the rant side of this, I'm fair skinned and it just showed up too dark on my fingers An Essie Chinchilly is about as dark brown/grey as I can go.
I'm pale with warm undertones. I agree that that YDKJ looks darker on than expected. I was unsure of how much I liked it when I wore it but I got compliments on it so that helped nudge it over to "like" status for me.