Opinions please! Engagement “match”

[MmeM124]

So, I’m trying to match my grandmother’s wedding band with some kind of engagement style ring. I am definitely considering having something custom made but I also need to figure out what I want. Spent about an hour today at Tiffany’s to look at what might work or be a jumping off point. We settled on a few that seem to work. Also these are just pretty to look at so I hope you enjoy!

I do have a couple I gravitate towards but any critique or input is appreciated!

1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)

 

[Aporchuk]

My favorite look is #4. The set blends so well together. Gorgeous!

 

[viewwing]

Definitely one of the true rings. They come across delicate,modern and classy

 

[Shopgirl1996]

All the rings are beautiful, but I also think #4 matches best.

 

[MatAllston]

I love #2. It looks nice with the band and it would look lovely on its own too.

 

[AntiqueShopper]

#2 - the 3 stone design really balances well with the ring

 

[skyqueen]

#4

 

[razl62]

#2 would be my choice, but all Tiffany rings are beatiful!

 

[limom]

#4.
Because I like round with round.
I also love the colored stones. Any special signification?

 

[JenJBS]

#4

Distant second is #2

 

[iseebearbears]

#4 looks best in my opinion. But it'll be best to have one custom made so it'll match perfectly. Remember to have fun during the process!

 

[Julezah]

#2.

loved seeing these rings!! Thank you for sharing.

 

[theprettymiss]

Definitely #4 but Id get it custom designed.

 

[Lillianlm]

I liked #2 the best, because if the shape of the stones and the overall balance of the setting, coupled with your grandmother’s ring. However, I prefer sapphires over rubies, and would really like 1 sapphire and 2 diamonds (or 1 diamond flanked by sapphires) in the #2 setting. Best of luck — they are all beautiful!

 

[MmeM124]

#4.
Because I like round with round.
I also love the colored stones. Any special signification?

Not particularly! Just wanting something more unique...but Ruby was my grandma’s birthstone so I did like that idea (although I gravitate more towards blue and sapphires generally).