I agree, the only reason i'm looking at the thin one is bc it's minimalistic and it will add the "pop" that you are talking about. I'm a guy, so the more minimalistic the better. Even though I do not like yellow gold on me, the pink gold has grown on me.I like the new, thin Loves a lot and I like the pop of color that one adds If the thin was also white gold I don't think I'd like it as much, it would be a big block of solid color. But, as you can see from the varied answers, everyone has a different preference and opinion so what matters is if you like the look of it! Make your own trend/style. Rock it.