Hmmm, this is a tough one. I don't have either style of bag in either color so mine might not be the best suggestion. However I have seen the ocean blue Clayton at the outlet and it is a darker more muted blue than the bright blue satchels I have seen posted here. It's not as vibrant. So I would say get which bag you think you would like better in terms of color. If you're drawn to that bright vibrant blue, go for the satchel,however if you want a more subdued darker color, get the Clayton. Of course if you want to branch out to the Clayton, this price point is a great time to try it. If you don't care for it, you can most likely sell it and get all of your money back. I can't wait to see which one you ultimately decide on.