Everyone, thanks for your compliments and votes. Looks like the ponytail ones are the winners. I will definitely keep both. I'm not sure about the lozenge one; I may keep it just because it's a great deal and if I can't use it myself, it will make a nice holiday gift.
Oops, I'm jealous you have 2 already. I would love a teal Gigi but since I already have a teal patent legacy shoulder, I chose another color instead.
Donnalyn, the zebra scarf would look great with walnut!
LegacyGirl, oh no...what is causing you to have second thoughts?
Karenina, definitely call ahead before you make the trip, like Vivi suggested.