Anyone out there have an opinion on this? Sweetie and I am looking at two rings. One is at Cartier, it is 1.22 G VS2 in the 1895 setting. Long story, but they originally misquoted us on the price and are honoring the original price, so now we can get a little bit of a deal on it. We have not seen this ring yet in person but it is being brought in tomorrow. In the mean time we found a ring at Tiffany that would be the runner up if the original price at Cartier had not been honored. It is 1.21 H VS1 in the 6 prong setting. Basically the same price as the ring above. So no-brainer, right, go with the one you are getting a deal on? Well, here is the catch. I got the GIA certs on both and the H stone at Tiffany is a cut grade Excellent, and the G stone at Cartier is only a cut grade Very Good. I was quite frankly shocked. For what Cartier charges I would expect the cut grade to be Excellent. Again, have not seen the Cartier ring in person yet. The Tiffany ring is gorgeous. Even though it is an H, compared to a D it still looked white (must be that Excellent cut!), and it just sings. So, I won't see the G at Cartier until tomorrow, but seeing the GIA certificate on it really burst my bubble since Cut is the most critical of the 4 Cs. Any thoughts?