Need some opinions on these two outerwears...

[Brandless]

The first one is from Talbots and the second is from Delias. I'm petite (4'11") and 98 lbs and mid-40s. I'm looking for something to go with casual jeans (my current fleece jacket from LE is too sporty) so I'll look a little bit more tailored when I shop. Which do you think?

 

[snoopylaughs]

Maybe you should look at Anny Taylor online or something else for a coat similar to the Delia's one but better quality
Personally I'm not a fan of toggle coats
I think Banana Republic has some?

 

[balihai88]

I like the style of the Delia's one better - it's more "contemporary" and versatile (seems like you could dress it up or down) but I agree with snoopylaughs, Delia's is not exactly high-quality/long-lasting stuff. Even Gap or Ann Taylor Loft (in addition to Banana and Ann Taylor) might have some more options?

 

[candace117]

the belted look is way cute and the cut of the Talbot's one may cut you off and make you look shorter?
I wouldn't get anything from Delia's though, I used to shop there when I was 13 (11 years ago) and their clothes are not great quality.

I'll echo everyone above: Ann Taylor for petites, Gap or even Old Navy if you want a cheaper wool coat that will still last.