Need some opinions on these 2 black bags (Spade, Coach)

Brandless

O.G.
Jun 9, 2007
2,363
139
I'm looking for a quality lightweight leather with topstitching and I just need some opinions on these two bags. I know I've been posting about the Kate Spade black bag but I had to be sure I exhaust all possible choices that I might like before deciding so bear with me.;) Here are the pics. The first one is a Coach Chelsea and the other last two are Kate Spade Flat Serena. Thanks!
 

Attachments

MissTiss

Shopping Issues
O.G.
Mar 2, 2007
4,996
2
tPF rocks my stripey socks!
I say the Coach. I have Chelsea bag (satchel) and the leather wears like Iron. It's great in the rain and resists scratching. I love it.
Plus I like that you can wear this one with blacks or browns. It's surprisingly versatile.
 

Kathyy

O.G.
Apr 30, 2006
875
3
Not a fan of the extra hardware on the Coach but I do love that leather. 4" is just the right depth for a shoulder bag, KS is a good size. I vote Kate Spade!
 

mayajuliana

~Mind, Body, Soul~
O.G.
Feb 23, 2007
2,307
2
The leathers are usually better on the Coach bag, but my concern is its heaviness...I'm torn. If you're expecting it to last, get the Coach.
 

Brandless

O.G.
Jun 9, 2007
2,363
139
The leathers are usually better on the Coach bag, but my concern is its heaviness...I'm torn. If you're expecting it to last, get the Coach.
Yeah, I'm quite concerned about the heaviness. It's been a while since I've carried a really comfy lightweight bag for everyday use. If the KS doesn't hold for long, I guess that's okay, that would be a good excuse to buy a new bag, right?:yes:
 
Top