My favorite mascara for years if not decades was Covergirl's Marathon mascara, in the green tube. It was cheap, had a great curved brush, waterproof, and kept my short, flat Asian lashes super curled. It's been discontinued and I have a few tubes stashed away but I need to quickly find a good replacement. I mostly want the waterproof and curling properties as I layer on other mascaras for volume and length. Thanks for your help!