Need help deciding my wedding band

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

mirrorbeyond

Member
Jun 11, 2014
117
186
Dear all, I recently lost my wedding band... it got smacked by some heavy items so two diamonds are lost and the band is completely out of shape. Tiffany will charge us for the repair so we just decided to replace it anyways (since it’s insured thank god!) I previously had a Tiffany Embrace Wedding band that goes classically with my Tiffany setting e-ring. But since we are getting a new one I wanted to see different ideas and my husband and I think vca has better quality and probably better service too so we took a look too and found the Romance ring fits my E-ring and fingers beat. So now I am debating between going back to my old wedding band or getting the new one from vca.

Tiffany one has bigger diamonds in front, and it’s such a classic pair with my e-ring. I have always loved my combo and never got bored. While vca, more discreet and its diamonds are probably better quality So makes it maybe a touch more elegant? Gals I need your opinions!

The first pic is my old ring. The second and third pictures are the vca one.
 

Attachments

  • 74CDBF7A-B1D5-4065-90FD-90B39E44F7B3.jpeg
    74CDBF7A-B1D5-4065-90FD-90B39E44F7B3.jpeg
    88.8 KB · Views: 380
  • CC26E155-B8D1-4B87-A377-EB7D6268F528.jpeg
    CC26E155-B8D1-4B87-A377-EB7D6268F528.jpeg
    99.3 KB · Views: 400
  • 92B06AD9-664E-41C7-943D-17BD6588FF27.jpeg
    92B06AD9-664E-41C7-943D-17BD6588FF27.jpeg
    89 KB · Views: 410
  • Like
Reactions: littleblackbag
Easy choice! That top set is perfection!

What size fingers do you have? And carat weight of your e-ring? Looks incredible on your finger!! :nuts:
 
Last edited:
Dear all, I recently lost my wedding band... it got smacked by some heavy items so two diamonds are lost and the band is completely out of shape. Tiffany will charge us for the repair so we just decided to replace it anyways (since it’s insured thank god!) I previously had a Tiffany Embrace Wedding band that goes classically with my Tiffany setting e-ring. But since we are getting a new one I wanted to see different ideas and my husband and I think vca has better quality and probably better service too so we took a look too and found the Romance ring fits my E-ring and fingers beat. So now I am debating between going back to my old wedding band or getting the new one from vca.

Tiffany one has bigger diamonds in front, and it’s such a classic pair with my e-ring. I have always loved my combo and never got bored. While vca, more discreet and its diamonds are probably better quality So makes it maybe a touch more elegant? Gals I need your opinions!

The first pic is my old ring. The second and third pictures are the vca one.
Tiffany one looks much better to me. The diamonds just pop!
 
Agree the original is the best. Must of been some hit to your poor ring to damage it that badly :sad:

It was the bed headboards in west elm factory store... they collapsed on my fingers when I was flipping them... weirdly though my e-ring is perfectly fine without any scratch! But I would to think that my weddjng band did a good job protecting my fingers, otherwise I will be end up in a hospital for sure!
 
Sorry to hear about your ring, but glad to hear that your fingers are OK. I also vote for the Tiffany wedding band. Just out of curiosity, was the charge to fix your old wedding band very expensive?
 
Top