Need help deciding - Coach Rogue or Dooney Caldwell

[Pennyhm]

I need help deciding which one. I have a few Dooney and the Coach would be my first Coach. I only want to get one. Both styles and sizes suit me. Images are from Google. Thanks for your help!

 

[IntheOcean]

I'd go do for the Rogue! I'm a bit biased since I like Coach and the Rogue is probably my favorite bag by this brand. And I have ever owned a D&B. But also, the D&B Cadwell looks much more casual, whereas the Rogue, I think, can easily be both dressed down and dressed up. So it's more versatile. I don't know what the interior of the Cadwell is like, but the Rogue has very lovely suede in the front and back pockets.

 

[Mariapia]

I love the Rogue

 

[Tomsmom]

Love the Rogue!

 

[Fimpagebag]

I would go for the Rogue.
I think you’ll find it more wearer friendly than the Caldwell.