Need help choosing between 2 necklaces!

[klb4556]

Thanks for checking out this post to help!

I really want a horseshoe necklace, I think it's something that really suits me and I saved up the money real quick and I am ready to pick one of these two!

I'm between the Tiffany 1837 horseshoe and the James Avery horseshoe. The only difference I see that kind of makes a difference to me and factors in is that the Tiffany chain looks really fragile and thin whereas the JA chain looks sturdy.

All opinions welcome!

 

[klb4556]

Here's James Avery.

 

[L etoile]

I prefer the Tiffany horseshoe, but have you considered a diamond one from Tiffany? I love the diamond and platinum horseshoe:

http://www.tiffany.com/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/horseshoe-pendant-16926914

 

[Crystalina]

I definitely prefer the Tiffany one!

 

[Shopgirl1996]

I prefer the Tiffany one, but have you checked out the Roberto Coin diamond baby horseshoe necklace? It's 20% off at Bloomingdales.


http://www1.bloomingdales.com/shop/...=Diamond&spp=49&ppp=180&sp=Null&rid=Null&pn=2

 

[valencialove]

Go for the Tiffany one as it has lovely detailing. The chain is much sturdier than you'd think. I have an arrow necklace from Tiffany with the same sort of chain, and I'm constantly tugging and playing with it. Its never broken, even after two years of continuous daily wear.

 

[staceyjan]

In ever had a problem w that time of Tiffany chain. DD whom is 11 wears one often and never had an issue.

 

[AmorNChanel]

I prefer the delicate looking chain in contrast to the horseshoe. It highlights the horseshoe better imho. So Tiffany is my choice. Good luck deciding.

 

[emchhardy]

There's one I saw on sale from Blue Nile that has diamonds.

This one is kind of different from Alex Woo:
http://www.alexwoo.com/little-luck-horseshoe-in-sterling-silver.html