Need advice deciding!!

[Lovefrommich]

Hello!! I recently got the black violet and ocelot small madeline and I love them both! But I saw the small cranberry today and it smacked me upside the head! GORRRRGGGGEOUS! Should I exchange the ocelot for the cranberry???? Is the cranberry too close to the black violet? I love the ocelot cuz its soooo different than anything I have but the fabric does scare me a little even though it seems very durable....I cannot have all 3. I think I love the ocelot and the cranberry equally. The ocelot is really lightweight and so snazzy and so unique. Cranberry could come along again in the future but what about ocelot? Do you think the ocelot will be as durable as it seems? Can't get cranberry outta my head! All opinions welcomed!! Thanks so much!!!

 

[tonij2000]

I would exchange ocelot for cranberry.

 

[ecj*waxy]

^^ I second this.

I don't think the cranberry and black violet are too close...they are totally different colors.

 

[arfmsu]

I would exchange ocelot for cranberry.

+1 I like the ocelot, but I always choose leather over fabric.

 

[iuvcoach]

Exchange. Cranberry and BV r not similar totally diff

 

[CeeBe]

Exchange for cranberry. I usually do fabric/prints in accessories and wallets. I prefer leather bags.

 

[NurseAnn]

Another vote for Cranberry. That color is amazing. I own it and love it. Fabric won't stand up to the same conditions that leather can.

 

[Maybi]

I had the small cranberry and ocelot on hold, got to the store and put them side by side, Cranberry all the way.

 

[LvoesBags]

I say cranberry too! I ordered the ocelot phoebe and didn't care for the feel of the fabric. Just not my cup of tea. But I love the new zebra print lol. Good luck

 

[zaara10]

I picked up a small cranberry @ Macy's last wk for my mom. It's so pretty! It would look great year round to me, esp right now in fall & the coming holiday season.
I vote cranberry.

 

[nc.girl]

I would probably return the ocelot and get cranberry instead. I think leather is almost always more durable than fabric. The ocelot is gorgeous, but you sound like you love the cranberry way more than the ocelot. BV and cranberry aren't similar at all IMO.

 

[E. Sarah]

Another vote for exchange. Leather trumps fabric.

 

[pink sapphire]

Another vote for exchange. Leather trumps fabric.

Igot my first Phoebe Cranberry Friday it is beautiful.

 

[Weekend shopper]

Another vote for Cranberry

 

[cupcakegirl]

another vote for exchange. Leather trumps fabric.

+1