My New Simple Twins - Not sure if both should stay...

[rainyjewels]

Dropped by Saks today to try on the black patent New Simples...the nude patent simples were brought out first and when I tried them on, it looked like my legs were just floating on air! And the black patent was so shiny and tall, I fell in love immediately!

So... I brought them both home. Now I'm having second thoughts esp considering I promised myself only one more pair of loubs since I just purchased (and decided to keep) my LV Mahina XL... I already have 2 pairs of simples...Does it make sense to keep both of these? Does the nude even go well with my skin tone? If you had to choose one, which one would you choose?

PS please excuse the modeling pics - had to crop out the mess in my apt..

 

[evolkatie]

I love New Simples so I'm biased. They are totally different from regular Simples IMO. Keep them They both look nice on you, I LOVE those nudes

 

[snf8]

those are both gorgeous! i say keep both since they are classic and will be able to wear them for a very long time! i love the new simples!

 

[techie81]

Keep both!!!! So gorgeous. Did you size up at all?

 

[bagpunk]

for some reason, i found the nude to look much better on you!

 

[laureenthemean]

The nude looks great with your skin tone! The black looks fab as well! I gotta tell you, whenever there's a "this or that?" thread on here, the answer is usually, "both..."

That said, I think you should keep both!

 

[Chins4]

They're both great basic staples - but if I had to choose one I'd go with the nude

 

[Arm Candy Lady!]

Nude color is gorgeous on you...especially if you do NOT already have a good neutral color...this is the SHOE for you

 

[purplekicks]

They both look really good, but if your other Simples are black or nude it wouldn't be a bad idea to return a pair of the New Simples for the sake of diversity. Either way, you can wear these shoes with practically anything.

 

[Shopalicious]

I would say keep both.. ! The nude color matches with your skin.. and one can never have enough black shoes..

 

[JRed]

i think the nude patent looks great on you. the black looks okay but there are other black shoes to be had. nude gets my thumbs up!

 

[afcgirl]

I vote nude! (Unless you plan on wearing them with dark jeans because I heard you can get color transfer)

 

[JetSetGo!]

They both look hot! But, I would keep the Nudes, and get a different pair in Black.

 

[shopalot]

They both look stunning on you!
I'm sorry I can't be much more help, you must keep both!

 

[8seventeen19]

Both are SOOO different. You really should keep both. I am starting to fall in love with that style!!