The Perfo is ok for me, it's the size of the covered hardware that bothers me. Wish they'd make it smaller but bigger than the regular covered hardware.
This bag looks fabulous and the leather is just so yummy. Then again a black city with ggh is a lovely and very versatile bag. But you should follow your heart and go with the one you think you are going to love and use the most.
I just got the giant city bag in crimson with silver hardware in the mail today. The color is SO beautiful in person. The pictures do not do it justice. I LOVE IT!
Great bag! I seems to have caught your eye if it made you change your mind. I say keep it and enjoy it ... while saving for your next bag, a Black GGH City!