Hmmm... tough one, but I would say that if you like it, then maybe you ought to keep it. My SO has good taste in bags, but every once in a while he may not love or "get" a bag I carry (eg. brown cambon mini reporter, he thought it was "bulky")... but that's probably the only example I could think of. I do trust his opinion, and might reevaluate my purchase if he hated it
-Minal
-Minal