I just received 4 mulberrys from the saks sale and I've decided to keep the tooled bayswater in "nude" which is a gorgeous color and I'm not sure it is much different fromthe oak. the bag is stunning. the others I received that are going back are the black tooled bayswater and the black phoebe and the black rosemary, all very nice bags but I have my black bags already set and I just wanted to see irl to decide on one. so they are going back to saks if anyone is looking for these bags they will reappear in teh 40 + 30% off sale section. I also have an apple green tooled bayswater which is stunning but I did not spray it before I used it and some tiny raindrops got on it and they are not permanent stains on the leather. so, do not use your mulberry until you spray with the colonil neutral spray.