Mid-range everyday earrings

What's the diameter of the Blue Nile pair?

If they're smaller than the first pair, I'd get the first. If they're the same, then Blue Nile.
 
What's the diameter of the Blue Nile pair?

If they're smaller than the first pair, I'd get the first. If they're the same, then Blue Nile.


The Blue Nile pair is 4.76mm and the Dana Rebecca is 5mm.

Of course the BN ones are on sale right now, so that's a bit tempting, but I think I'll go with the Dana Rebecca.

Thanks everyone for your opinions!