Good for you that you wrote a complaint and the Saks manager responded promptly. I can't wait to find out how much the giftcard is worth!
I went into the Phoenix Biltmore Park Saks the other day, mainly looking for lingerie on sale. I hadn't been in the store in months, and headed first for the "Petites" department and couldn't find it. My pet peeve: department stores moving whole departments and you have to wander around and waste time looking...
I approached a SA and asked, "Where is the Petites department located now?" She proceded to give me a lecture about how they don't have Petites anymore and yak-yak-yak how they have so many designers who make clothing proportioned for petites, how easy it is to get things altered. I couldn't believe what I was hearing and put up my hand to shut her up, saying, "I don't need to hear you lecture me."
Then I walked over to lingerie, found a couple of great bargains, and discussed the Petites situation with the SA who helped me. She told me she gets
constant complaints about no more Petites department and says she lives in fear they will get rid of their Plus Sizes (she was a beautifully dressed, made-up, and coifed larger-size lady), too.
My point here (to not be totally OT) is that Saks does NOT have good customer service, so don't be expecting it when you shop there.
Back to your experience with the tags. I would bet that the SA was planning to use the tags for some kind of scam where she would affix them to cheaper bags and try to return them after Xmas. Maybe with the help of a family member or friend. Why else in the world would she offer to remove the tags? Perhaps, (you said she was a cosmetics SA) she thought you were giving the bags as a gift and wanted the tags removed. But, if so, you would've wanted to keep the tags!
In Phoenix/Scottsdale there is no comparison between the customer service at Saks and at
Nordstrom. Frankly, I might "shop" for bags at Saks, but I would buy from somewhere else where I could get a discount. And I would definitely have a phone conversation with the store manager about the tags business.
Congratulations on being happy with your purchase and I hope the bags perform just as you want.