I'm bumping this, because I got my Meow shipment today!
Supposedly they ship faster normally, but they were closed for a few weeks for the holidays and had a back-log. Anyway, the package was super cute with cheetah print tissue paper and a few free samples-- gotta love that
I ordered the Pampered formula, which is indeed matte, although not chalky. It feels similar to the EM Semi-Matte, but I suspect it might look a little better on.
All the different shades and names get a little confusing... There's different levels of depth/darkness: 0=Lightest, 1=Very light, 2=light, 3=medium and 4=dark. Then each level comes in all different undertones. I ordered all of the non-cool-toned shades in level 2. All of the different colors were a better match for me than Bare Minerals, with the exception of one, which looked orange.
For reference, my skintone is peaches & cream, nc20-25 in MAC depending on time of year. The #2 Chartreux (yellow-peach) was a perfect match on my arm, but I haven't tried it on my face yet. I think I might have to mix Chartreux 2 & 3 to get the best match. I'll report back when I actually wear it on my face!