I would categorize Cartier (at least the models I've seen) as a "dress" watch, as opposed to a casual style.
Rolex and TAG are both sportier.
Do you know the model of Gucci he lost? If you can find a picture we can look up the description and try find out the mm size.
I personally like how the Explorer looks on me, as I have a larger wrist and the DateJust is quite small in comparison. I also find the Explorer more sporty/casual, and more youthful. The DateJust is classic Rolex, demands instant recognition, but...I sometimes think it's too mature for me right now.
Personally not a fan of TAG, but there are thousands, if not millions, of guys who love the brand!
http://www.amazon.com/GUCCI-Mens-YA...1_81?s=watches&ie=UTF8&qid=1311076238&sr=1-81
This is the one he lost. He mentioned TAG awhile back, but he also said he doesn't like it because the dial is too big for his wrist. His dad pasted down to him a Cartier (don't know which model it was, but it was very big on him so he doesn't keep it).
I like the DateJust and the Explorer. The DateJust is $6,400 and the Explorer is $6,200. Of course I can't afford neither at this very moment.
I've looked at other Cartier models, their dials range from 39-42mm?? That's huge huh?
I am just looking for a model (either Rolex or Cartier or any other respectable watch maker name) to set it as my goal to save up for his "IT" watch.
I really like the Explorer. Also take a look at the Submariner (attached). I was reminded of how fab it is when I came across that shot today in Harper's mag.
For Tag, the Carrera is gorgeous and sporty.
I recommend also looking at Bell & Ross, IWC and Swiss Military. Men have a lot of great casual options!
I will check the Carrera out. I will also look at the ones you recommended, thank you!
My fiancé has the dark blue face tag carrera and he LOVES it and always gets a lot of compliments. The dial is 36mm on his I think? And he has a small wrist. When we went shopping, he preferred this to the rolexs he saw. And I loved the thinner bezel on them because its easier to dress up if need be.
He likes the band and the dial of this watch, which he lost.
http://www.amazon.com/GUCCI-Mens-YA...1_81?s=watches&ie=UTF8&qid=1311076238&sr=1-81
I am trying to find one that fits him. Dressy and casual.
I like the Tag Aquaracer 500. Tag Heuer is a very popular brand that uses ETA movements. Rolex uses in-house movements and has a strong history; of course you are going to pay a lot more for that. Tag Heuer $2800 vs. Explorer $5800.
I prefer the Rolex Explorer over the DJ, just based on looks. Not a fan of the Explorer II though. Datejust is a little more dressy and has a lot of options in dials. You could also look at the Milgauss for an all-around watch, or the Submariner for a more sporty piece.
Which Gucci model did he own?
I also like the Explorer over the DJ, just because it looks more simple. I called the Rolex provider yesterday and I got a quote of $6,200 on the Explorer... where did you see $5,800?
What's the difference between ETA movements and in-house movements?
Yes, I am looking at an all-around watch. I actually want to get him a watch asap, and my current budget is around 1k. Any recommendations? his old one looks something like this.
http://www.amazon.com/GUCCI-Mens-YA...1_81?s=watches&ie=UTF8&qid=1311076238&sr=1-81
I don't know the dial size of that watch, but that one fits him perfectly.