Hi everyone, This is my 1st post but I frequent the forum. I am trying to decide between the medium carryall or medium satchel in black signature. Just looking for an everyday structured bag in this size range. I tried the large carryall and it's just too big for me, as well as the book tote. Also, I'm looking for a little more structure so my purse doesn't turn into a junk bag. I like the carryall but had concerns about the short zipper and if I'd outgrow it. I know I'll have to order it or get it from another store that still has them. I like the satchel but sometimes it looks plain to me. It was really my first choice but when I actually went to buy it, I wasn't that impressed. Also, I have an lv speedy 30 and thought the satchel has the similiar barrel shape. They are both cute bags. Any posts about your experience with these bags or opinion would be great. Thanks and have a great day.