I totally think the Clydebank is more practical too. I mean, sheesh, the McGregor is supposed to be an overnighter. I don't care though. I'm going to be buried with mine. And my Alstons. And my Venezia. And my, well, you get the picture. lolI love the look of both of them, but I like the Clydebank better myself. I feel like it's more practical. But the McGregor is more unique-looking/different. So I guess it's whether you want something that's more practical or something distinctive. With all my LAMBs I went for distinctive, so I'll be using a Mandy of mine and then my arms will get tired and I'll be thinking "Damn, why didn't I get one I could put comfortably on my shoulder?!?"