Marc Jacobs Stam vs Tivoli

I had a similar black-bag search (other than Epi and Suhali) and at the time LV really didn't have what I was looking for so I went with Chanel's jumbo black caviar flap with gold hardware. Of course, after I bought this, LV comes up with the black denim, the Mahina, and the Motard Biker and Motard Pochette. LOL

Anyway --- now I'm looking for a black bag with silver hardware and the Epi Alma or even the Noe is making me think real hard about getting it.

In answer to your question --- although the MJ Stam is also a gorgeous bag, I would go with the Tivoli. Classic, timeless, and versatile. Good luck with your decision!!