I have a few of the Citychic eye pallets, mascara, smudge brush, and the double ended brightener. They are okay, in my opinion, but nothing to scream about. I do like the brush the best of what I have. I think the brightener (crayon side) is too waxy and the powder can be replicated easy enough in any other brand. The idea is fabulous though. The shadow in the pallets doesn't seem to blend nearly as well as MAC brand.