Malachite...GHW or SHW? Help!

[Blushingnude]

I'm so confused.
I begged and begged my SA for a malachite B and she was so kind to order it for me (PO) in GHW. Now I think I made a mistake and should have gone for SHW instead and maybe even in a Kelly (I wear both B and Ks). I think the GHW is too much "pop" for me on a color (I have both hardwares on my bags and most of my bags are neutrals).
I guess I won't decide until the bag comes but I'm getting so anxious!
(I found this photo online of Caroline Stanbury. The K shw looks so chic and modern and it's what made me confused in the first place!)

 

[weibandy]

I'm so confused.
I begged and begged my SA for a malachite B and she was so kind to order it for me (PO) in GHW. Now I think I made a mistake and should have gone for SHW instead and maybe even in a Kelly (I wear both B and Ks). I think the GHW is too much "pop" for me on a color (I have both hardwares on my bags and most of my bags are neutrals).
I guess I won't decide until the bag comes but I'm getting so anxious!
(I found this photo online of Caroline Stanbury. The K shw looks so chic and modern and it's what made me confused in the first place!)View attachment 3755172

Gold will look great!

 

[LovEmAll]

I think both gold or silver look amazing on Malachite...just a personal preference of choosing one versus the other. To me, Malachite is like anemone in that sense, it looks great with either HW.
I think you went the right choice with the B though (but maybe I'm biased as that's what I have and love it - mine is with PHW though).

Hope you love it when you see it!

 

[27leborse]

IMO I much prefer GHW, as it enhances the warmth of Malachite whereas PHW enhances the cool tones. However, I do tend to prefer more green based colorations over blue in general anyway. If you tend towards blue tones, than I would think PHW would be preferable but really they both compliment the color beautifully.

 

[bagidiotic]

Another vote for ghw

 

[eternallove4bag]

Another vote for GHW! I am biased since I have B30 malachite with GHW which hands down is my favorite bag out of everything I own[emoji172][emoji172]... here's a picture of it borrowed from my IG

 

[QuelleFromage]

I think both PHW and GHW complement Malachite wonderfully.

 

[Madam Bijoux]

Mine has GHW. I think GHW always complements the bag's color more than PHW (with the possible exception of light blues like Ciel).

 

[mcpro]

Ghw !! That is the perfect combo

 

[odette57]

I'd prefer a GHW on a malachite. It is listed on my wishlist for a Kelly.

 

[babybaby2011]

I vote for GHW

 

[Rami00]

Both hardwares work on malachite, I personally like the phw for more fresh and crisp look.

 

[MYH]

I have ghw on my malachite Kelly too and love it.

 

[LovEmAll]

For reference ... but honestly, this color looks amazing with either HW. Wait to see the bag and if you love it, go for it. There are very few colors i would turn down a bag for due to hardware and this is not one of them. Malachite is a dream! [emoji172][emoji172][emoji172]

 

[Nui]

+1 ghw [emoji1327]