I voted for Oceano. Both are great colors that work well with the ruffle accents. What tipped the scale for me is most dark navy/marine blue bags seems to be more uniform and rigid looking in style. The Magnolia ruffles really soften the dark color and give it a strong, but very feminine look.
I like both the gray shine and the oceano, but between the two, I would go for the gray shine. I think that the light color allows you to clearly see the ruffles and details very clearly and I like that.
Ok, you guys are making me reconsider my oceana decision??? I thought I had decided on oceano because I don't have a blue bag, and just ordered the wheat asher, do you think the grey shine is too close to wheat???