Oh, it's not a magic scarf; it's Magic MaiTai, who shows off any scarf to its best advantage. She looks great in any of them. Heck, I bet she'd look great with a piece of toilet tissue artfully knoted around her neck!
But to the point, so far, Brides de Gala has a slight edge with Tigre not far behind. However, I'm reserving my vote until I see the last design.
Oooops - she beat me to it, and I'm changing my mind. It's Pani La Shar Pawnee. That darn old Indian has never looked so good!
I seem to remember a thread in which a certain someone pulled off a bit of trash bag couture in response to a similar statement....!! I believe lily has the thrown down a new gauntlet here.
More on topic I agree that Pani La Shar gets my vote. Its funny how the scarf that was my least favorite laid flat is my preference when worn. I love that quality of H scarves.