Yes, the Magenta Isabelle and Fuschia Lindsey are different enought to justify owning both. First, they are two different bags. Magenta is a bright, beautiful purple pink. I thought the fuschia was not so bright and kinda dull. With that said, I can see someone owning both with no problem.
w0wowoz I love that Magenta
I think you NEED one of those - it's HOT!
Really nice smooshy leather too.
Between DD and I we have the Madison Fuschia Abigail and the Magenta Isabelle and I just took some quick pics for you. Sorry, but it's getting dark here now so the flash had to be on. They look deeper irl but hopefully you can see the shade differences well enough. We also have the Fuschia Legacy Duffle so I threw that one in the pic too. Obviously we're a house of pink loving Barbie girls lol!
Magenta - purple pink and in some lights actually looks more purple than pink. Very close to last year's Madison Berry Patent color.
Madison Fuschia - pink and lighter than the Legacy Fuschia
Legacy Fuschia - vibrant hot pink
HTH!