Madonna is told her little African baby may have to return home
Madonna with David Banda, whom she hopes to formally adopt
Madonna's controversial adoption of an African baby was under threat last night amid accusations that the child welfare expert overseeing it has become too close to the case.
Penstone Kilembe has been banned by the Malawian government from travelling to Britain to review the progress of 23-month-old David Banda, who has been in the care of the singer for nine months
Last night Mr Kilembe said the development could result in the adoption being called off.
According to a newspaper report in Malawi, the Minister of Women and Child Development, Kate Kainja, accused him of obtaining an air ticket to London and money from Madonna herself without his government's approval. The minister refused to allow Mr Kilembe to travel to assess the case, accusing him of "personalising" the matter.
She suggested that by accepting funding from Madonna he had compromised his neutrality.
"We have already contacted Madonna that someone else and not Kilembe will come to assess her, because we feel Mr Kilembe personalised the whole issue when other people can go," the Minister told the Malawi News.
The revelation is likely to prove hugely embarrassing to the 48-yearold singer and could halt the adoption process altogether.
Last night Mr Kilembe confirmed that he had been banned from making the trip, but denied that he personally asked the American star for a plane ticket.
He claimed that the decision to exclude him from the final decision on whether or not Madonna is allowed to keep David may result in the child being sent back to Malawi.
"What this means is that the whole adoption process may crumble and David is sent back to his village," he said.
David has been living with Madonna, her film director husband Guy Ritchie and her two children since last October.
The High Court of Malawi originally appointed Mr Kilembe, who is director of Child Welfare Services, to travel to the UK to monitor how David was settling into his new family life. His testimony was expected to be crucial in the final ruling next year on whether the celebrity couple should be allowed to adopt the child permanently.
There was strong speculation that he might judge Madonna's superstar lifestyle and close media attention unsuitable for the youngster.
Last week Mr Kilembe claimed that social services in povertystricken Malawi did not have enough cash to pay for two visits planned to see David in Britain.
A five-day trip in May to Madonna's homes in London and Wiltshire had to be cancelled for lack of money, he said. A first visit was instead scheduled for later this month with a follow-up trip in December.
"We have been unable to travel because of logistical problems," Mr Kilembe said on Friday. "It requires some resources for me to travel."
But if Madonna did try to solve the problem by funding his visits, she risks being accused of hoping to secure a favourable report.
The Malawi minister's anger appears only to complicate her case. Justin Dzonzi, a human rights lawyer who led a 65-member rights group challenge to Madonna's adoption, also said the minister's decision could halt the adoption process.
"The minister cannot change what the court set by having another person to do the assessment. The court will not listen to anyone else apart from the one it appointed," he said. Dzonzi filed the case arguing that Malawi laws forbid international adoption and therefore the government broke its own laws by granting Madonna an interim adoption. A spokesman for Madonna declined to comment.
The Daily Mirror
Madonna with David Banda, whom she hopes to formally adopt
Madonna's controversial adoption of an African baby was under threat last night amid accusations that the child welfare expert overseeing it has become too close to the case.
Penstone Kilembe has been banned by the Malawian government from travelling to Britain to review the progress of 23-month-old David Banda, who has been in the care of the singer for nine months
Last night Mr Kilembe said the development could result in the adoption being called off.
According to a newspaper report in Malawi, the Minister of Women and Child Development, Kate Kainja, accused him of obtaining an air ticket to London and money from Madonna herself without his government's approval. The minister refused to allow Mr Kilembe to travel to assess the case, accusing him of "personalising" the matter.
She suggested that by accepting funding from Madonna he had compromised his neutrality.
"We have already contacted Madonna that someone else and not Kilembe will come to assess her, because we feel Mr Kilembe personalised the whole issue when other people can go," the Minister told the Malawi News.
The revelation is likely to prove hugely embarrassing to the 48-yearold singer and could halt the adoption process altogether.
Last night Mr Kilembe confirmed that he had been banned from making the trip, but denied that he personally asked the American star for a plane ticket.
He claimed that the decision to exclude him from the final decision on whether or not Madonna is allowed to keep David may result in the child being sent back to Malawi.
"What this means is that the whole adoption process may crumble and David is sent back to his village," he said.
David has been living with Madonna, her film director husband Guy Ritchie and her two children since last October.
The High Court of Malawi originally appointed Mr Kilembe, who is director of Child Welfare Services, to travel to the UK to monitor how David was settling into his new family life. His testimony was expected to be crucial in the final ruling next year on whether the celebrity couple should be allowed to adopt the child permanently.
There was strong speculation that he might judge Madonna's superstar lifestyle and close media attention unsuitable for the youngster.
Last week Mr Kilembe claimed that social services in povertystricken Malawi did not have enough cash to pay for two visits planned to see David in Britain.
A five-day trip in May to Madonna's homes in London and Wiltshire had to be cancelled for lack of money, he said. A first visit was instead scheduled for later this month with a follow-up trip in December.
"We have been unable to travel because of logistical problems," Mr Kilembe said on Friday. "It requires some resources for me to travel."
But if Madonna did try to solve the problem by funding his visits, she risks being accused of hoping to secure a favourable report.
The Malawi minister's anger appears only to complicate her case. Justin Dzonzi, a human rights lawyer who led a 65-member rights group challenge to Madonna's adoption, also said the minister's decision could halt the adoption process.
"The minister cannot change what the court set by having another person to do the assessment. The court will not listen to anyone else apart from the one it appointed," he said. Dzonzi filed the case arguing that Malawi laws forbid international adoption and therefore the government broke its own laws by granting Madonna an interim adoption. A spokesman for Madonna declined to comment.
The Daily Mirror
Madonna needs to care for the boy for the sake of the boy... he can't go back. 