Madison Magenta!!! Which one though???

Which Madison Magenta???

  • Go with Julianne, you already know you like her!!!

  • Diversify and get the shoulder bag! It's BIG enough!!!


Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

lovecoachmore

Member
Aug 21, 2008
6,435
7
I personally think that the Madison magenta bags (all of them) are the most gorgeous shade of pink I've EVER laid eye's on!!! YUMMY!!!

I've owned Julianne (this is the 2nd time around) and like her well enough. I also have 2 Lg. Sabrina's and like those alot aswell. I've never owned the Madison shoulder bag, and have only seen them IRL a couple of times. I'm headed towards either the Julianne or the shoulder bag in Magenta, but need some input on which one!!!

I think it would be good to diversify with the shoulder bag, since I already own the Julainne and 2 Sabrina's, but fear she'll be too small for me. The measurements on the bay seem to vary between 14 & 15in. long.

Who has any of the Madison shoulder bags??? Are they a generous size for someone who needs atleast the size of the Lg. Sabrina???

Should I play it safe and wait for the Julianne in magenta or go forward and get the shoulder bag??? I love the look of the shoulder bag, so the ONLY THING holding me back is the fear of the size!!

If you own these bags (or know alot about them) please weigh in for me!!!

TIA gals!!!
 
I say if you already have the Julianne and own some sabrinas, go w/the shoulder bag... I tried this on in the store, and was tempted to buy it at the time, but didn't because I didn't want to pay FP, but if you can get one for a good deal, I say go for it! IMHO, I think the madison shoulder bag is a good sized bag, its not too big and not too small... G/L deciding!
 
I have a black Op Art shoulder bag...Love her! She is a bit smaller than the lg. Sabrina though, so if you absolutely need that much room, I would say wait for the Julianne. But, you also don't sound like you LOVE! the Julianne, and I think you're right about diversifying, so if the size issue is flexible, I say go for the shoulder bag.
 
Thanks for the opinions so far!!! I think I can go with a little less space then the Lg. Sabrina. Hopefully it's not much though. There's a magenta Julianne on the bay right now, but it looks like it's got some wear. I'm one who likes to buy EUC only when buying used unless the deal is too good to be true!!!
I've also always LOVED the look of the shoulder bag. It's just the perfect shape IMO!!!
 
I own the Madison Shoulder Bag in Black and tan. It is a lovely bag and a great size for everyday. I love the shoulder strap/Cross body option on this bag. I say go for the Magenta Madison shoulder bag.
 
I have two Madison shoulder bags, the parchment spectator and the magenta, which I just got a couple of days ago. They are really roomy, and the magenta is gorgeous! I think you'll love it.
 
I love the magenta madison bags. I don't own one because I haven't seen one in the outlet yet. I don't own colored bags, but would probably scoop this up!
 
The shoulder bag is absolutely beautiful...I love it! But, it is smaller than a large sabrina and if you need at least a large sabrina, I don't think it will be big enough for you...

If you think you can go for something smaller in size and want to diversify then I wouldn't hesitate buying a shoulder bag! It still has plenty of room. :graucho:
 
Last edited:
I say go for the shoulder bag even tho I'm personally partial to Julianne...one Julianne and two Sabrinas in your collection is good enough...diversify and go for the shoulder bag! :tup: