Hey, Oops...I can post photos of both together if you want, but the Madison tote is the same leather as the other Madison pieces (Olimpic, or Olympic...I don't recall how they spell it). It's a bit thicker and nicer IMO than the garcia on the Maggie, and the bag does not puddle and fold over quite as bad either, although the Maggie retains some structure because of the way the center and sides are designed. Also, the Madison is still new (I haven't carried it). I like the Madison magazine tote SOOOOOOO much better than the Maggie!! Not just the leather (although the Garcia leather works much better on the Maggie and looks nicer than on the '08 Legacy IMO), but I just prefer everything about the Madison better...and it stays put on my shoulder. It's very comfy and light too, and a great size! The color is quite diff. between the lilac Maggie and lavendar Madison. In some lights the Madison looks pink. So basically if you love you Sabrina and the leather on it, you will be fine with this tote. The only thing is that the Olimpic leather is very variable with the texture and glaze, and I personally prefer more texture, so that's why when I saw the bag I loved, I jumped! Now if I can just find a green one that I love! I'm going to get that and the ikat in navy for the settlement instead of PCE since it's 30% off.