Leather Ali. Hand down. The legacy leather fits the legacy style of the bag. My boss (in her 50's) told me (in my 20's) that my brown Ali reminded me of a saddle bag she had when she was my age. This was the best compliment that I had received about my Ali's (I have received SEVERAL. It is my most complimented bag, by far.) So get the leather. The signature and the legacy stripe scarf is just too much at once. The scarf and the leather is beautiful!