Hi guys. I have really weird sizing on my fingers where basically my rings will ONLY fit on my ring fingers. I typically wear my love ring on my right ring finger but when I go out I wear more substantial diamond rings or my VCA rings. I would love to be able to wear my love ring on my index finger but it doesn’t fit. So recently I purchased a love wedding band that fits ONLY on my index finger…way too big on any other finger. I know I wanted an index ring because I wished I had one so many times when styling my jewelry but now it’s seeming like a waste to have it for just one finger when that money could go towards other pieces. What do you guys think? For context my other Cartier pieces are 4 diamond love bracelet and JUC necklace.
Love band for one finger only
- Thread starter Nad21
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
Doesn't seem weird at all; I have two rings sized for my index and they definitely won't fit on other fingers. Aren't most people's fingers all very different sizes?
This is all normal. A select few may be able to wear the same ring size on multiple fingers, but most aren’t so lucky. I have to decide which finger I want to wear a ring on, and size it specifically for that finger.
The love ring in particular, with its flat shape, is finicky and needs to be sized for the particular finger you need to wear it on.
The love ring in particular, with its flat shape, is finicky and needs to be sized for the particular finger you need to wear it on.
All my fingers are different sizes. And my right hand fingers are slightly bigger so sometimes I can’t even switch hands. But I still own a lot of rings 
I just have to live with the fact that every ring I own can only be worn by one finger (and maybe only one hand!).
I have 3 love rings: rainbow, pave and the two-band cross (discontinued style). They all only fit my middle finger.
I just have to live with the fact that every ring I own can only be worn by one finger (and maybe only one hand!).I have 3 love rings: rainbow, pave and the two-band cross (discontinued style). They all only fit my middle finger.
I thought it's normal for a ring to only fit 1 finger lol.. I did buy a silicone guard so my larger ring (for right index finger) can fit my right ring finger. Problem is the guard will tend to move when I wash my hands so I don't use it often. Also, my index finger is the largest finger but my middle finger bone is bigger so if I manage to wear my index finger ring on my middle finger, it will be slightly loose. So I buy rings specifically for each finger. Example the louder, more impactful ring to be worn on index finger, slimmer ring for ring finger.
I find wearing a slim ring on index finger a little weird. That's just me though..
Edited to add: I do have 2 rings which comes with an adjustable chain so I could wear it on any finger.
I find wearing a slim ring on index finger a little weird. That's just me though..
Edited to add: I do have 2 rings which comes with an adjustable chain so I could wear it on any finger.
It’s completely normal to have a ring that may fit only one finger. It’s not normal to me that very many people have the same size ring and index fingers lol
My pave Love can fit my index fingers on both hands and one middle finger.
My pave Love can fit my index fingers on both hands and one middle finger.
Phew! I thought I had very strange hands for a minute! My index finger is at least a US size and a half bigger than my ring finger.
I actually like a slim ring on the index finger; I wear an Hermès chaine d'ancre there sometimes. It's a good place for almost any ring IMO.
I actually like a slim ring on the index finger; I wear an Hermès chaine d'ancre there sometimes. It's a good place for almost any ring IMO.
