Louis Vuitton Twist or Chanel Med Caviar flap?

[gettinpurseonal]

I currently own a So black LV Twist and a Chanel beige Jumbo Caviar Classic flap. I never use the Jumbo flap because it is a bit too large for me. I absolutely love the Louis Vuitton twist and its clever closure. I am trying to decide whether to buy another Twist in beige, or sell my jumbo in exchange for a med/large.
I currently have over 100 bags, including obe Jade green Lambskin Jumbo and three other Med/L flaps in chevron olive green calf, black lamb chevron, and silver lamb quilted, so this is not my entire collection, just the two involved in this question:


And here are 2 beige LV Twists and an example of a smaller Chanel flap:

 

[LPR200]

If you know you love the LV, why not get another one?

 

[gettinpurseonal]

If you know you love the LV, why not get another one?

Haha, good point, but I also love Chanel classic flaps and love the texture of Chanel caviar. So it’s a tough decision.

 

[dbcelly]

That beige / taupe jumbo looks so yummy tho... It makes sense to sell if the size doesn't work for you.

If you don't have other LV twists (that so-black is BEAUTIFUL btw), I'd say get another LV twist since you have a couple of M/L already

 

[sashinla]

Voted for the ML classic flap! That beige clair is such a classic color and look

 

[LV_4ever]

I vote twist. It is such a clever bag. And I love the versatility of the strap.

 

[superchelly]

If the LV twist is more your style, I'd say go with that. For myself, I prefer the Chanel classic flap, but in a smaller size.

 

[ilytemporarily]

Considering you have three other M/L Chanel purses, I’d say go for the twist.

 

[mockey999]

What did you end up deciding? I’m debating between the twist or the YSL sunset. I’d purchase the sunset new (I’m in Spain right now) and would likely buy the twist second hand- so would come out to around the same price. I just tried them both in the store and am equally excited about both. Votes??