Looking for a new bag...

[Miss_Q]

and it comes down to these 3 bags:

Kristin Leather Zip Top Tote- Brass/Peony

Kristin Leather Satchel- Silver/Yellow

MADISON LEATHER SOPHIA SATCHEL-Silver/Shimmer

I can choose 2 of these but don't know which ones. Please help! TIA!

 

[LindaP]

The leather on the Kristin's is soooo nice and comfy that I'd chose those.

 

[ashleyroe]

yellow satchel.

 

[ralewi]

Kristins love love love the leather on kristins. I have 2 myself.

 

[nanabags]

Love the Kristin in yellow for the spring summer and the sophia will get you through every season.

 

[monkeytoes79]

I agree. The yellow and the Sophia.

 

[LIblue]

I would pick one Kristin and the Sophia. Both Kristins are great bags but if I was choosing one for myself I would go with the yellow satchel.

 

[LoveTheC]

I'm probably the only person on here who doesn't like the yellow kristin. I vote for the other two; love the shimmer sophia!

 

[BonBonz]

I'd pick the sophia and one of the Kristins. Personally, I'd go for the yellow satchel since I prefer silver hardware over gold or brass and it's such a pretty yellow color. Good luck deciding!

 

[Bag Fetish]

I agree. The yellow and the Sophia.

I agree!!

 

[melissatrv]

This is a tough one....because I have a feeling on June 1 those Kristins are going to hit the outlet. I am not keen on the fabric the sophia is made of....too prone to having issues/stains. Out of the two Kristins I vote peony....it is THE color of the season it seems

 

[lacey_stiletto]

A friend bought the yellow satchel this weekend - it's lovely but yellow is not a color for me. Worked great for her because she's a warm strawberry blonde, lovely with her coloring and wardrobe.

The Sophia doesn't do anything for me but I love the Peony Kristen. I don't think I'd buy two Kristens, though.

 

[emilybug]

I'd get both Kristins. The Kristin line is my favorite and I don't care for Sophia at all, so my opinion is a little biased!

 

[Carley29]

I have the yellow kristin and it is a beautiful bag. Go for it!!

 

[ckarachr]

I had read on here that the Peony (Coral) Kristins have been deleted. I'm not sure if that's all styles in that color, but I would wait on that one to see if it hits the outlets.

Also, the shimmer Sophia is made of the same material as the Poppy shimmer stuff, so if you search on here for the shimmer Sophia, there are a couple stories of SA's actually steering people away from them just because the material is so delicate and hard to clean. The bag is absolutely gorgeous and I love the color (and I love all things sparkly and shimmery!), but I would be so afraid of getting it dirty! All three of your choices are beautiful though!


ETA: Here is the link to a recent thread discussing the Shimmer Sophia.