First of all, I am SO glad I found this site, finally, girls who care as Coach just as much as I do! Anyway, lets cut to the chase. A few weeks back, I was all set to order the Lily XL satchel in black, and when I went to the sales counter, the SA told me the computer was showing it also available in walnut (only 55 available in that color). There was no picture they could show me, so I paced the store for about an hour deciding what color to get. They showed me a bleecker in "walnut", and it was a deep, rich brown so I decided to go for it and order the walnut Lily. A few days later she arrived, and to my surprise, looked NOTHING like the deep, dark walnut I was shown in the store. Its a lot lighter, almost like a whiskey without the reddish hue. And I'm not quite sure I like it! Its nice, but not what i was expecting. Have any of you ever seen the walnut Lily? So what is a girl to do? Should I a) keep it because no one else will have it B) exchange it for a black XL lily when its available again in January, or C) exchange it for a medium Lily?????? Please help me girls!