I agree with all the ladies who said that you should only keep it if you love it, that goes for all three items.
I'm also considering returning all three, and just getting a black reissue.
Ohhh, I'm glad to hear you kept the reissue and returned the CL's! I agree that the CL's with the bag were very blingtastic haha ... but the bag with a pair of sexy black peep toes would make for a gorgeous combination!!
Hmm, I'm not sure I agree with your assessment of the metallic reissues ladydeluxe... the silver isn't spray painted on, and not prone to peeling ... metallics, and all bags, are definitely prone to fading (especially on the corners, etc.), but the metallic reissues are made from a pretty durable distressed calfskin, and as a result, hold up nicely.