Legacy Soft Trunk 2019 Vs. Soft Side Trunk 2023

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Syrenitytoo

Syrenitytoo

O.G.
Apr 25, 2007
1,252
228
#1
I need help deciding .... the new L.V. Soft Side Trunk in Monogram or the 2019 Legacy Soft Trunk in Monogram. My pros and cons are the size of the Legacy fits more, the vachetta is patina'd already and there is not as much hardware to tarnish. The pro's of the new side trunk is it's edgy vibe which could go in and go out. Thoughts anyone? I have an option to pick up a pre-loved in excellent condition of each so the price is similar. If I go with the older style I would use my Loop Hobo chain strap to add some gold. My concern about the gold corners on the new version is that they did not add feet ... I do not know why not. It will constantly be setting on the corners. I tend to hang my one and only trunk to avoid corner wear. All thoughts are welcome. Unfortunately, I cannot get to try them out. The older style could be returned but not the newer one.

Image.jpeg

Image2.jpeg
 
#2
The Women's version, all the way. The Men's version is boxier, the VVN (that was pre-tanned in the factory, I'm not fond of those) can be scratched up just as much as the hardware, I wouldn't recommend to focus on that aspect. As already can be seen on the photos, the construction of the Men's one makes the side VVN edges inevitably bent, and since the design is so similar to a normal trunk, it makes it look like hard-sided trunk "from Wish" :D Not literally, but since it is more similar to a classic trunk, that makes its feel like a lesser version of that, not a playful new interpretation. Which is the case with the Women's version. It is a smart and graceful take on the classic, using its codes way more elegantly, while playing with its own softness. The other one is just a lumber-free trunk, this one is a beautifully feminine soft bag with trunk accents. Also it does retain more of the visual codes of the trunks, and that literally makes it "more Vuitton" than the other one. It is a superior design.
The only thing I find really cool about the Men's version is that they came up with those flower rivets. But since they forgot to make sure that they stand straight, they are all over the place, if you once looks at them, cannot be unseen.
Also — this is just a personal pet peeve of mine — I hate those weird zipper pulls that they use for the Men's seasonal pieces. I really hope that Pharrel will change them, because everytime I see one, that renders anything unsellable for me.
Sorry for the long post, and I know that there is a huge factor of personal taste and preferences when people look at these two models, but I just wanted to emphasize that there are quite a few objective reasons why I believe most Vuitton enthusiast would consider the Women's version to be an overall better design. I recommend that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nekostar0412, gagabag, wrapitup and 2 others
#4
I don’t have either, but I also prefer the new version; I just think it’s more elegant and versatile. I know the hardware getting scratched up on the bottom isn’t ideal, but hey — at least it’s on the bottom! Scratches are inevitable and a sign that a bag is well-loved and well-used, so I’d try not to worry about them too much. You could also maybe leave the stickers on the bottom corners and just let them peel off naturally if you wanted, or maybe find something that would just cover the underside part of the metal that doesn’t show. Both are nice and it’s a matter of opinion, but I would choose the newer version based on my personal style. Good luck with your decision! :heart:
 
  • Like
Reactions: wrapitup and BULL
#6
Thanks for help with my decision! I really appreciate it! What would you use to treat the vachetta? I’ve pretty much let go of all my vachetta bags except my Bumbag for this reason but this trunk is to die for. Has anyone used Collonil Carbon Pro?
 
#9
I don’t have any or it but I think I would choose the newer soft trunk. Too much Vachetta gives me anxiety. The soft trunk looks classy enough to bring it to an evening event while still cool for semi casual. So it’s versatile enough. The 2019 version looks too casual.

@BULL always makes solid technical comments.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Cats&Bags and BULL
#10
Syrenitytoo said:
How do you like it so far?
Click to expand...
It's one of my favorite bags. You can dress it up or down. It fits everything I need, including reading glasses and sunglasses. I like that it's different. I get so many compliments when I carry it. I was with three friends when I bought it at the boutique. A couple of them live in a community where LV, Chanels, Dior, etc are very commonplace. They all gasped when she brought it out to show me. :biggrin:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Classy&Fab
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top