Legacy or Carly?

[pompilit]

I have store credit and I'm just itching to get something. I went into the Coach store today and thought I'd get the black legacy shoulder bag, but then I saw the small leather carly in parchment and can't decide. What do you ladies think, go with the parchment carly, or the black shoulder bag?

 

[yhassan]

You seriously can't go wrong with either!! They are both fabulous!

 

[I Chanel]

legacy shoulderbag in black

 

[Aslan]

I like the color of the parchment better than the black, but I prefer the style of the Legacy to that of the Carly. I have to go with the Legacy, although I'd prefer it in pond, white, or natural.

 

[pompilit]

Thanks everyone!

Thanks bchleo! I actually have the shoulder bag in whiskey already and LOVE it. I was thinking of getting it in a different color and just saw the black one in the store today. This would be my 2nd shoulder bag, but I agree with you, it's a great styled bag and I love it.

 

[Kiari]

Why not the legacy in white? Kind of a meet in the middle?

 

[willowsmom]

Tough choice. I have 2 shoulder bags (plum suede and whiskey) and a medium parchment Carly and I love them all for different reasons. I'm not into black bags lately (went through a period of time in my 20s when EVERYTHING I wore was black. Ok, now I sound old), so I'd vote for the parchment since I love the contrast of the deep mahogoney with the ivory and I love the hardware. But I'm biased by color and to be honest, I think the shoulder bag is perhaps my all-time favorite style.

Wow - looking at what I just read, I'm sure i didn't help you at all! I'm sorry, you just gave us a very hard choice!

 

[tlloveshim]

I voted shoulder bag just because I love the Legacy bags the most! I have a medium Carly too though and I think you'd be happy with either.

 

[MarieG]

I prefer the Black Shoulder Bag! Let us know what you decide and post pics pls!

 

[pompilit]

Thanks everyone! I basically decided to go with the shoulder bag. I just love that style and it's a perfect bag with all the outside pockets and such. I ended up with a new dilemma though (I'm horrible with being indecisive!!) - get the shoulder bag in black or in the new pond? Decisions, decisions!! LOL

Thanks again everyone, all your comments helped a lot.

 

[ms-whitney]

You seriously can't go wrong with either!! They are both fabulous!

yessssss ITA!

but they are two different styles. the legacy is more of a casual everyday but the carly, while can be casual, the brighter shine on the gold makes it more dress up if wanted.



good luck choosing! it's not easy.

 

[Bethy]

Definitely Legacy!

 

[disney16]

I vote for the Carly

 

[couturequeen]

Legacy!