Layering - which one to get?

Vintage would be my vote (more practical and substantial), but more red color, similar to sweet color :smile: though both look great on you!

I dont know if it’s the lighting, but I agree - the color of the sweet carnelian is better than the color of the vintage. However, I like the vintage size (actually one could easily make the argument for either size on you - I don’t like the sweet personally on me, but here it does look good on you). If they have another vintage with color closer to the sweet, go for that. If that makes sense!