Yellowtulip- You never updated here with the outcome of your phone call, I would really like to know how that went. There are two reasons why I am curious.
1) I'm not sure if it is just me, but I have a serious lack of understanding of why people would send a single e-mail to a company and then take the time to come here and complain before re-sending the e-mail or calling! Is our society that anti-social? It seems more often than not, when someone complains about the poor service they have received on a website, they have not attempted to call to rectify the situation.
Do you not get junkmail? Do you answer every single e-mail you get? I think that (not just with business but in life) if something is really important you really just need to pick up that phone and call. Sometimes an e-mail cannot express the severity of the problem AND it can easily get lost in a flood of mail. When you have something that needs to be taken care of at work or with a friend and you don't hear back from an e-mail, wouldn't you pick up the phone and call then???
I just don't get it. It seems like so many people have this issue and they act like they are helpless as to where to go or what to do next- and they hate the company for it, which just really isn't fair.
2) I am also writing to give a different perspective on the company. I have had extremely positive experiences with Lauren Merkin customer service. I have purchased several bags from them and have gone to their sample sale (great deals!). But after I had purchased my first bag from them, a clutch, several months, maybe even a year later I had an issue with the spring closure. They fixed it no charge, no questions and were very helpful and pleasant. Since then I've been a loyal customer.
So unless things have really changed I believe your situation was a fluke. Things slip through the cracks in every business. They are a pretty small company and I'm sure get overwhelmed at times. While sending you a "used" bag is pretty crappy, things like that happen in every business occasionally and my thought is that you were just the unfortunate one in a thousand that had an unpleasant experience. I am curious to see what happened once you actually got in contact with them because I would be shocked if they didn't rectify the situation.