Tough. Phoebe works for dressing up and down. Duffle is classic. The color is nice. For me, it would come down to the one that I would get the most use out of. Duffle is a bag you can keep in your collection a long time but, for me, the color is more trendy than timeless. The color you're choosing for phoebe would serve you for years to come.
Now if that's not an issue for you than choose the pop of color and get the duffle. Depending on how long your ban is, you'll be able to find either if them later for less money
Now if that's not an issue for you than choose the pop of color and get the duffle. Depending on how long your ban is, you'll be able to find either if them later for less money